The Thanksgiving Shopping List, Built From the Menu

A Thanksgiving shopping list is much easier to get right when you write it from the menu instead of from memory. Memory is good at the turkey and the pie, and much less reliable about the celery for the stuffing, the cream for the potatoes and the foil you’ll need to cover the bird while it rests. The full list below is sorted by store section, roughly in the order you’d walk the aisles, and each item carries a note on whether it belongs on the early trip or the last one. Cross off anything that isn’t on your menu and add whatever your family won’t do without.

Start with the menu, then pull the list out of it

Writing the whole menu down first is what makes a Thanksgiving shopping list complete. Put every dish on paper, including the small ones that are easy to skip, like the gravy, the cranberry sauce and whatever goes on the table next to the rolls. Then go through each recipe and copy out every ingredient, down to the butter and the salt. It takes a while, but it’s where the missing heavy cream gets caught on Sunday instead of Thursday morning. There’s more on why that step takes longer than it looks in where the real work hides between a recipe and a grocery list.

 

Once you have the raw list, take it to the cupboard. Most households already own the flour, the sugar and half the spices, and Thanksgiving is when people come home with a third jar of ground cinnamon.

 

Copying ingredients out by hand is also the step an app can do for you. In A Better Meal, a planner for the week’s dinners that runs on real recipes, the grocery list can be generated from one recipe, from several at once or from the next 3 or 6 days of your plan. The plan itself starts from your preferences, and you can bring your own recipes into the app, which matters when the stuffing is the one your grandmother made. The list reads by aisle when you’re in the store or by recipe when you want to see which dish each item is for. It can’t see your cupboard, so the pantry check is still yours to do. There’s a short tour of how the list and the plan connect on the site.

How to split a Thanksgiving shopping list into two trips

The simplest way to split a Thanksgiving shopping list is by how long each item keeps. Anything shelf-stable or frozen goes on an early trip, a week or two before the holiday. Anything that wilts, goes stale or has a short date goes on a last trip, a day or two before you start cooking.

 

A frozen turkey is the main reason to do the early trip at all. The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service says a turkey thawing in the refrigerator needs about 24 hours for every 4 to 5 pounds, so a 16 to 20 pound bird needs four to five days in the fridge. Count back from Thursday and that bird has to start thawing by the Saturday or Sunday before, which means it has to be in your house before then. Clear a shelf for it first, because a big turkey in its pan takes up most of one.

 

Buying early also gets you ahead of the items that run short. Stock, canned pumpkin, cranberry sauce and the fried onions for green bean casserole all get thin on the shelves in the last few days before Thanksgiving, and the stock is usually the first to go, so buy it on the first trip and buy more than you think.

 

The last trip is for anything that wilts or goes stale: herbs, salad greens, green beans, bread, rolls and cream. A fresh turkey goes on this trip too, since the FSIS turkey roasting guide says to buy a fresh bird only a day or two before you cook it. If you can, do the last trip on Monday or Tuesday. Wednesday afternoon is when the store is at its busiest and the fresh herbs have mostly been picked over.

 

FSIS also publishes a Thanksgiving food safety guide that covers the rest of the turkey’s schedule, from thawing through leftovers.

App screenshot showing a weekly meal plan and grocery list

See what your week could look like.

Tap once, get the plan and the list together.

7-day free trial, then $6.99/month
or regular price $83.88 $39.99/year SAVE 50%+

Try it in the app

The Thanksgiving shopping list, by store section

This list follows the order most grocery stores are laid out in, so you can work through it in one pass instead of doubling back to produce for a single lemon. That’s the whole case for sorting a grocery list by aisle. Items marked early can go on the first trip and items marked last belong on the final one. Quantities depend on your recipes and your headcount; for the turkey, the usual starting point from the USDA is about a pound per person.

Produce

  • Yellow onions, more than you think you need, since the stuffing, the gravy and the green beans all want them (early, stored somewhere cool and dry)
  • Garlic (early)
  • Potatoes for mashing, russet or Yukon Gold (early, kept somewhere cool and dark)
  • Sweet potatoes (early)
  • Carrots (either trip)
  • Fresh cranberries, if you’re making the sauce from scratch (early, they keep in the fridge)
  • Apples or pears for pie (either trip)
  • Lemons (either trip)
  • Celery (last)
  • Green beans or Brussels sprouts (last)
  • Salad greens (last)
  • Fresh sage, thyme, rosemary and parsley (last)

Meat and poultry

  • Turkey, frozen (early, at least a week ahead) or fresh (last, a day or two before you cook)
  • Turkey wings or necks, if you like to make gravy stock ahead of time (early, they freeze well)
  • Sausage for the stuffing, if your recipe uses it (last, or early and frozen)

Dairy and eggs

  • Unsalted butter, several pounds of it, since butter is the item people undercount most (early, it freezes)
  • Eggs (either trip)
  • Cheese for a gratin or a cheese board (either trip)
  • Heavy cream (last, and check the date)
  • Whole milk (last)
  • Sour cream or cream cheese (last)
  • Whipped cream for the pie (last)

Pantry and baking

  • Chicken or turkey stock, a couple of cartons more than the recipes add up to, for loosening the gravy and reheating the stuffing (early)
  • Canned pumpkin purée, which is a different thing from pumpkin pie filling, since the filling comes already sweetened and spiced (early)
  • Evaporated milk, if your pumpkin pie calls for it (early)
  • Canned cranberry sauce, if someone at your table prefers it, and someone usually does (early)
  • Flour, cornstarch, granulated sugar and brown sugar (early)
  • Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves, or a jar of pumpkin pie spice, plus dried sage and thyme (early, after checking the cupboard)
  • Vanilla extract (early)
  • Cream of mushroom soup and fried onions for green bean casserole (early)
  • Pecans, or marshmallows for the sweet potatoes (early)
  • Boxed stuffing mix or cornbread mix, if you aren’t starting from a loaf (early)
  • Pie crusts, if you’re buying them (frozen ones early, refrigerated ones on either trip)
  • Olive oil, vegetable oil, kosher salt and black pepper (early, after checking what’s left)

Bread

  • Dinner rolls (last)
  • A sturdy loaf or two for the stuffing (last, at the early end of it). Most stuffing recipes want dry bread, so buy it two or three days ahead and leave it cubed on a sheet pan, or dry the cubes in a low oven.

Drinks

  • Wine, beer or cider (early)
  • Sparkling water and soda (early)
  • Coffee and tea for after the pie (early)
  • Ice, the day before or the morning of, and more than seems reasonable if the drinks end up in a cooler because the fridge is full of turkey

Kitchen supplies and everything else

  • A roasting pan with a rack, or a disposable foil roaster. If you use foil, set it on a sheet pan, because a foil pan bends when you lift a full turkey out of the oven. (early)
  • An instant-read meat thermometer, and fresh batteries for it (early)
  • Heavy-duty aluminum foil (early)
  • Kitchen twine (early)
  • Disposable baking pans for sides that won’t fit in your own dishes (early)
  • Plastic wrap and zip-top bags (early)
  • Containers for leftovers, including a few you don’t need back so guests can take a plate home and turn it into a holiday leftover sandwich on Friday (early)
  • Paper towels, napkins, trash bags and dish soap (early)

Frequently asked questions

What if the turkey is still frozen on Thanksgiving morning?

A turkey that’s still frozen on Thanksgiving morning can be thawed in cold water or roasted straight from frozen. FSIS’s thawing guidance says cold-water thawing takes about 30 minutes per pound, with the water changed every 30 minutes, and the turkey should be cooked as soon as it’s thawed. Roasting from frozen is safe too, but FSIS says it takes at least 50 percent longer than roasting a thawed bird, so dinner will run later than planned.

What temperature does a turkey need to reach?

A turkey is safe to eat once it reaches 165°F, according to FSIS, checked with a food thermometer in the thickest part of the breast and the innermost parts of the thigh and wing. If the stuffing is cooked inside the bird, the center of the stuffing needs to reach 165°F as well. That’s the reason the thermometer is on the list.

What should you ask Thanksgiving guests to bring?

Thanksgiving guests are most help bringing things that travel well and don’t need your oven, like rolls, a pie, wine or cider, ice, or a salad they dress when they arrive. Give each person one specific item and take it off your own list as soon as they say yes, so the table doesn’t end up with three pumpkin pies and no rolls.

Author

  • The team at A Better Meal is dedicated to making healthy eating faster, easier, and more enjoyable for the whole family!

4.8 from 2,400 App Store reviews

Trusted by 50,000 families

"Finally an app that actually plans my week instead of just saving recipes. — Sarah, App Store"

Dinner, handled

Generate your first plan in under two minutes

Try a Better Meal

7-day free trial, then $6.99/month
or regular price $83.88 $39.99/year SAVE 50%+

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message

4.8 from 2,400 App Store reviews

Trusted by 50,000 families

"Finally an app that actually plans my week instead of just saving recipes. — Sarah, App Store"

Dinner, handled

Generate your first plan in under two minutes

Try a Better Meal

7-day free trial, then $6.99/month
or regular price $83.88 $39.99/year SAVE 50%+